Finance

Finance
Investments

Sunday, June 19, 2011

"Micro finance Effects in Bangladesh" Findings of my MBA Research paper


Research findings:
Research was carried out on six MFIs in Bangladesh. Effective interest rate is actual interest rate which is much higher than the Flat interest rate, MFIs charges. Main intention of my research is to find out the actual interest rate of MFIs and how Borrowers are getting effected by this.
Most important findings are given Bellow:
Flat interest: 
Flat interest is a method following the interest on the whole amount once and amount will depreciated by each installment. MFIs in Bangladesh and some other countries are following the Flat rate method. In addition MFIs added compulsory savings, which is great benefits for the lenders. Bellow table showing the flat rate of some leading company and actual interest rate including saving and service charges:

Flat interest and Actual interest differences:
MFIS
Flat Interest rate
Actual interest rate with service charge and savings
Asha
15%
85.77%
Brac bank
15%
69.70%
Buro Bangladesh
15%
85.74%
Deep
15%
54.58%
Grameen Bank
10%
43.44%
Tage
15%
96.70%


Effective interest rate are showing in different stage ( including fees, savings)
Six MFIs effective interest rate in different stage:
MFIs
Nominal rate interest
Fees
savings
Repayment plan
EIR without fees and savings
EIR with fees
EIR with fees and savings
Asha
15% Flat
1%
11.50%
Weekly
33.19%
35.40%
85.77%
Brac Bank
15% Flat
5%
6.13%
Weekly
33.19%
44.25%
69.70%
Buro Bangladesh
15% Flat
0.80%
7.60%
Weekly
33.19%
34.85%
85.74%
Deep
15% Flat
2%
11.50%
Weekly
33.19%
37.61%
54.58%
Grameen Bank
10% Flat
0%
7.33%
Weekly
23.11%
23.11%
43.44%
Tage
15% Flat
1.16%
15.33%
Weekly
33.19%
35.77%
96.70%


Loan overlapping:
Loan overlapping means, taking loan from different MFIs even same institute by different member of a family. MFIs  are also tensed on this meter. due to much debt borrowers are unable to pay any of the loan and ran way. As MFIs has strong policy to collect the installment, forcing them to sell their remaining property. This trend can not drive upward the Bangladesh. In the bellow table showing that 82% borrowers are in loan overlapping. 6% are extremely in danger point.

Overlapping
No of Borrowers
Percentage of Borrower
one MFIs
9
18%
Two MFIs
11
22%
Three MFIs
20
40%
Four MFIs
7
14%
Five MFIs
3
6%
Total
50
100%


From my research i came to know that MFIs can not help the poor by charging high interest interest rate. some people might say that they have seen in news paper or some other research paper , Micro finance help 10 Million people in Bangladesh and did a lot. But if you want to know ask the borrower how much they are benefited? 
Its true that Micro finance is most applicable in south Asia and invented in Bangladesh in a bigger form. so its need modification to make it as a weapon to fight against poverty.